Position directory
Positions we recruit: Insurance Underwriting, Claims and Agency Operations
Start a Search Financial Headhunters Salary Guide
Financial Headhunters: Hiring strategy for underwriting, claims, and agency operations
This is what we do all day: recruit accounting, finance, banking and insurance professionals.
- Controller
- CFO
- VP Finance
- FP&A Director
- Accounting Manager
- Director of Accounting
- Assistant Controller
- Tax Director
- Treasury Manager
- Internal Audit Director
- Senior Accountant
- Financial Analyst
- Head of Financial Reporting
- Commercial Lender
- Chief Credit Officer
- Business Systems Finance Lead
How long did your last search take?
How much did the empty seat cost while you waited?
Every week a finance seat stays empty costs you in overtime, late closes and work that waits. We go straight to people already doing the job.
01
Hiring scope by function
This category covers back-office and customer-facing roles. You need to distinguish between underwriting tasks and claims administration. Underwriters require knowledge of specific lines like general liability or workers comp. Claims staff need state licenses for adjusting. Agency staff focus on bond desk management or account servicing. Avoid lumping these functions together during interviews.
Scope the role based on your current systems. Ask if they know Guidewire or Duck Creek. Someone with property experience often struggles with workers comp due to the audit requirements. Do not expect transferable skills between commercial surety and personal lines claims. Focus on the specific system and line of business.
- 01Check state adjuster license status for claims roles.
- 02Verify payroll audit experience for premium auditor candidates.
- 03Confirm bond program setup knowledge for contract surety roles.
- 04Match Guidewire or Duck Creek expertise to your platform needs.
02
Interview guide for insurance roles
Ask questions that force the candidate to explain their logic. Avoid situational questions that allow for hypothetical answers. Focus on past decisions. Require them to describe a policy rejection or a denied claim.
Listen for specific technical details. They should mention NCCI codes or WIP schedules without prompting. If they talk in vague terms, they lack the depth needed for these technical roles.
Before you interview a candidate, we verify their specific line history against your actual processing volume. We ask for the exact insurance forms they processed last month and check for discrepancies between their reported tasks and the administrative reality of your firm. You face a hard trade-off between hiring for system speed versus product depth. A candidate who knows your specific rating software might lack the deep line knowledge to handle complex policy rejections, while a product expert may struggle to adopt your workflow. We investigate if they prefer manual entry or automated adjudication and confirm their past experience matches your current backlog of files. This conversation identifies if they can handle your daily document load without training on the basics of the policy form.
- 01AskExplain the last commercial general liability policy you declined and why.
- 02AskDescribe how you handle a contractor bond request with poor working capital.
- 03AskHow do you verify payroll exposure for a workers comp audit?
- 04AskWhat is your process for verifying a state adjuster license in a new jurisdiction?
03
Common hiring mistakes
Managers often prioritize experience length over line knowledge. A ten-year auto veteran does not translate to a commercial property role. The state classification code nuances require deep knowledge that takes time to acquire. No upfront fee. You pay only if you hire.
Another mistake is ignoring the regulatory status. If a claims adjuster lacks the proper state license, your operations stop. Do not assume they can obtain it later. Verify the current license status before the final round.
- 01Hiring for transferable skills when line-specific knowledge is required.
- 02Overlooking the difference between field and desk adjusters.
- 03Neglecting current state adjuster license checks.
- 04Ignoring the lack of rating system familiarity.
04
Candidate motivation and trade-offs
Candidates in this space move for specific reasons. Underwriters look for higher authority levels. If they are capped at a certain premium limit, they will look for roles with more autonomy. Claims staff move for better desk-to-field ratios or better software tools.
Understand that an account manager in a small agency might not fit a large carrier environment. The systems and workflows differ significantly. You are choosing between a generalist who learns fast and a specialist who can work immediately.
- 01Candidates switch firms to increase their individual underwriting authority.
- 02Better software tools often drive claims staff to change employers.
- 03Agency staff seek roles with more direct access to carriers.
- 04Premium auditors move for more efficient route planning and system integration.
05
Credential verification
Understand the difference between certifications and licenses. A license like a state adjuster permit is a legal requirement for the role. A certification like CPCU or AFSB is a mark of professional training but is not legally required for the work.
Always check the status of a license through the state department of insurance. Do not rely on the candidate saying they are licensed. Use their NPN to confirm the active status. For certifications, contact the issuing body to confirm the candidate holds the designation in good standing.
- 01State Adjuster LicenseRequired by law for claims adjusting.
- 02CPCU/AUProfessional designation for underwriters.
- 03AFSBSpecific credential for surety bond professionals.
- 04APACredential for premium auditors using NCCI codes.
14 positions in this family
- Commercial Lines UnderwriterUnderwriters perform detailed inspections of agency accounts to manage the balance between new premium targets and loss limits.
- Surety Underwriter (contract surety)Underwriters challenge contractor financial projections while spotting failing work schedules before the contracts become a formal insurance claim.
- Claims Adjuster (field and desk)Adjusters interpret policy language to set liability and document decisions to support coverage determinations during legal contract review.
- Premium AuditorReconcile payroll registers with tax filings to verify policyholders pay accurate premiums based on verified business data and plan records.
- Commercial Lines Account Manager (agency)Managers process technical requirements for renewals and endorsements to prevent lost accounts by catching errors in the documentation.
- Personal Lines UnderwriterEvaluate risk and bind personal lines insurance policies within assigned authority limits.
- Underwriting AssistantTask-oriented administrative support role for commercial or personal lines underwriting desks.
- Surety Account Manager (agency bond desk)Management of contract and commercial bond portfolios at an insurance agency.
- Claims ExaminerManaging complex loss portfolios and liability investigations for commercial and personal lines.
- Subrogation SpecialistDirectly manage recovery efforts for insurance claims by investigating third-party liability and pursuing reimbursement.
- Loss Control ConsultantEvaluates risk factors and safety protocols at commercial client sites to mitigate insurance exposure.
- Premium Accounting SpecialistThis role manages premium reconciliation, billing cycles, and accounts receivable for commercial insurance portfolios.
- Senior Claims AdjusterDirectly manage high-value property and complex indemnity claims from assignment through settlement.
- Senior Commercial Lines UnderwriterEvaluates commercial risks for policy issuance and profitability management.
No title matched. Send us the title you need.
Questions people ask
How do I know if a candidate has enough technical skill?
Ask them to describe a specific workflow for a task you perform daily, such as setting up a contract bond or auditing a payroll account.
Does the state classification code complexity demand specific certification?
No, it proves training but does not replace the need for experience with your specific line of business or software.
What if the candidate has the license but not the experience?
You will need to invest in training. This is only viable if they have strong knowledge of the line of business or related rating systems.
How do I distinguish between junior and senior underwriting levels?
The key is authority level. A senior underwriter works independently on complex risks and has authority to bind policies above a certain premium threshold.