Article
How to hire a Tax Preparation and Audit Staff team
Start a Search Financial Headhunters Salary Guide
Financial Headhunters: Determine if your tax season needs temporary support for high volume returns or permanent staff to manage complex multi-entity filings.
This is what we do all day: recruit accounting, finance, banking and insurance professionals.
- Controller
- CFO
- VP Finance
- FP&A Director
- Accounting Manager
- Director of Accounting
- Assistant Controller
- Tax Director
- Treasury Manager
- Internal Audit Director
- Senior Accountant
- Financial Analyst
- Head of Financial Reporting
- Commercial Lender
- Chief Credit Officer
- Business Systems Finance Lead
01
Team Structure and Levels
Use seasonal preparers for high volume individual returns. Use staff associates for complex business filings and audit support. Enrolled Agents manage IRS notices and client representation. Audit associates perform field work and documentation tasks. CAS staff handle ongoing client accounting and bookkeeping needs. Match the level to the specific technical volume and software environment. Juniors need more review time. Seniors handle files independently.
Assess if the need is temporary or permanent. Seasonal staff provide flexibility during busy months. Permanent staff allow for year-round planning and complex projects. Contract engagements require specific terms per assignment. We do not employ or insure contract workers. Each hire must fit your current workflow complexity. High complexity requires CPA progress or active EA status. Basic preparation requires strong software fluency.
- 01Tax Preparer for seasonal throughput.
- 02Enrolled Agent for IRS representation and notices.
- 03Tax Associate for business filings.
- 04Audit Associate for EBP or niche industry work.
- 05CAS Staff for monthly client ledger maintenance.
02
Interview Questions
Ask about specific software workflows. Ask how they handle complex 1065 or 1120S schedules. Ask for their process when a client lacks documentation. Ask how they manage multiple deadlines simultaneously. Ask about their familiarity with state-specific filing requirements. Listen for concrete steps, not general theories. Watch for clear communication of technical hurdles.
Focus on their practical experience with Drake, Lacerte, UltraTax, or CCH Axcess. Ask them to describe a difficult audit notice and their specific resolution steps. Ask for their process on workpaper documentation in CaseWare or CCH Engagement. Verify their ability to represent a client via Form 2848. Check if they have managed installment agreements.
- 01Walk me through your process for preparing a complex 1065.
- 02How do you handle a missing asset schedule from a client?
- 03What specific features in CCH Axcess do you use most often?
- 04Describe your experience with EBP audit workpapers.
- 05How do you track your progress on CPA exam sections?
03
Common Hiring Mistakes
Ignoring software compatibility is a mistake. A preparer who knows ProSeries might struggle with CCH Axcess initially. Do not hire based on credentials alone. An active CPA candidate may lack the speed required for seasonal tax volumes. Focus on their actual work samples and references. Do not overlook the need for strong communication with clients during audit procedures.
Do not underestimate the time required for onboarding. Even skilled staff need training on internal file naming and review processes. Avoid hiring staff who lack specific industry niche knowledge if your firm relies on EBP or nonprofit returns. Do not assume all tax staff can handle audit work. These roles require distinct skill sets.
- 01Overestimating a candidate's speed with new software.
- 02Mixing tax and audit skill sets improperly.
- 03Neglecting to check current PTIN status.
- 04Skipping detailed reference checks for contract roles.
- 05Hiring a generalist for a specialized niche.
04
Credentials Explained
An active PTIN is a basic requirement for tax preparers. The IRS issues this. It proves they are authorized to prepare federal returns for compensation. It does not prove technical proficiency. AFSP records are optional but indicate a commitment to annual filing updates. An Enrolled Agent status requires passing a comprehensive IRS exam.
Passing exam sections indicates technical interest. Verify license status through the state board. Workpaper tool certifications identify basic operational exposure to CaseWare or CCH Engagement. Confirm license standing directly with the board before extending an offer. We offer a candidate replacement guarantee on standard search agreements. The applicable period and exact terms are set out in the signed client recruiting agreement.
- 01PTINAuthorized for return preparation.
- 02EAIRS representation and tax authority.
- 03CPAProgress status and licensing.
- 04Software certificationTool proficiency.
- 05State registrationLegal filing authorization.
05
When to Move
Move when your current staff utilization exceeds 50 hours per week during non-peak times. Move when audit workpapers remain incomplete due to resource gaps. Hire when you turn away new business because of capacity limits. Hire when your experienced staff spends too much time on basic 1040s that junior staff could handle. Hire when technical notice volume stalls your daily workflow.
Move if your current team lacks the specific software knowledge to keep up with filing deadlines. Move when you need specialized expertise for EBP or construction audits. Replace or add staff when current turnover impacts client service quality. Adjust your staffing when your volume of S-Corp filings increases significantly. Keep your resource levels aligned with your actual return volume and audit pipeline.
- 01Overtime exceeding sustainable levels.
- 02High volume of unassigned notice work.
- 03Turning down work due to labor shortages.
- 04Need for specialized audit industry experience.
- 05Inability to meet client deadlines for business returns.
06
Which related hiring decisions are worth comparing?
Questions people ask
What is the difference between tax and audit staff?
Tax staff focus on return preparation and tax planning. Audit staff focus on workpaper documentation and field testing.
How do I verify a candidate's software skills?
Ask for specific workflows within the software and verify their history with that exact program.
Are seasonal hires better than permanent staff?
Seasonal hires offer volume relief during busy months. Permanent staff allow for year-round stability and complex file ownership.
What is a PTIN?
A Preparer Tax Identification Number is a requirement from the IRS to prepare returns for pay.